Denial of the announcement in the media entitled "Livno courts are record holders in the number of citizens' complaints"
Regarding the statements published on 18th May 2022, at Relaxportal and Livnoonline, as well as Radio Livno, the public was informed that according to the portals "Livno courts are record holders in the number of citizens' complaints", and among other things they state: "We have a Municipal Court in Livno with 50 appeals, Basic Court in Banja Luka with 27 appeals, Municipal Court in Sarajevo with 28 appeals. There are also County Courts.
The County Court in Livno seems to have followed the example of the Municipal Court in Livno, they have as many as 22 appeals, and there is also the County Court in Sarajevo with 22 appeals", says Mitrović (Ljubinko Mitrović, Ombudsman for Human Rights of BiH).
In order to properly and completely inform the public,
the real situation is completely different.
Namely, these are not complaints, as regular legal
remedies that are submitted in accordance with legal regulations, as the
Ombudsman for Human Rights of BiH Ljubinko Mitrović points out. These are
submissions that the Ombudsman calls complaints, by which they ask for the
information when some specific case is going to be resolved in the Cantonal
Court in Livno.
The Institution of the Ombudsman for Human Rights of
BiH - Field Office in Livno, etc. according to the records of the Cantonal
Court in Livno sent 19 such submissions of "complaints" to this court,
to which this court responded immediately.
Among other things, the letter states that a large
number of cases are unfounded and immediately closed (eg: appellants submit an
appeal, which is registered and subsequently found to be inadmissible, ie the
appellant is dissatisfied with the verdict or does not use a regular remedy (thinking
that the Institution of the Ombudsman may reverse the judgments as they see
fit…)). It often happens that some complainants immediately after filing a
lawsuit open a case in the Institution of the Ombudsman, Field Office in Livno,
requesting that the work of the court in the same cases to be monitored. The
fact is that during 2021, only one recommendation was made to the Cantonal
Court in Livno in a case in which a violation of the trial was found within a
reasonable time.
The letter from the Institution of the Ombudsman
emphasized that the number of cases in the Field Office in Livno, related to
courts, could not be an indicator of the real situation in the judiciary of
Canton 10.
According to the submitted list of 20 appeals received
by the Field Office in Livno in 2021, it was determined that one appeal relates
to the case of the Municipal Court in Livno, one appeal relates to a case not
sent to the Cantonal Court in Livno to be resolve the appeal process, one
complaint related to a relatively recent administrative dispute and the case is
still open in the court, for 5 complaints the Field Office in Livno received
information directly from the court office, while 12 complaints related to
cases where the Field Office in Livno requested information in submissions on
cases, and received answers to all inquiries. It should be emphasized that all
cases have been resolved and that the Institution of the Ombudsman for Human
Rights of BiH, Field Office in Livno, has been informed about it.
It follows from the above that the Ombudsman Mitrović
hastily and without verification gave the said statement which damaged the
reputation of this court, and it is necessary for him to publicly deny his
statement.